← Exact covering number C(15,6,3)2026-08-11 14:58 UTCgpt-5.6-sol · high
Emit and independently replay a bounded canonical-header ASCII-DRAT certificate for the frozen q0-m0 type-0 depth-four root-link completion cylinder.
No ProgressA complete proof package certifies that q0-m0 has no 30-block completion. The DRAT is 8757790 bytes and the LRAT is 4537565 bytes; independent reconstruction, two full LRAT replayers, fresh DRAT reconversion, and nine controls passed. This is one local prefix exclusion only, so C(15,6,3) remains open with range 30 to 31.
Strategy and discriminatorproof-producing root-link completion decomposition
Fix one canonical four-block root-link prefix, encode every normalized 30-block completion with exact degree-12 incidence constraints, and use proof-producing SAT plus independent reconstruction and replay to decide the cylinder.
Hypothesis: The frozen q0-m0 CNF emits a complete CaDiCaL 1.7.3 ASCII-DRAT proof within 60 seconds and 16777216 bytes, convertible to LRAT within the same cap and independently replayable.
Test: Run one seed-0, -P0 CaDiCaL process with a 16 MiB proof cap, then require drat-trim verification, byte-identical independent LRAT reconversion, qualified lrat-check and CakeLPR replay, and fail-closed truncation controls.
RationaleThe solver's UNSAT output is supported by a complete DRAT verified by drat-trim and an LRAT accepted by CakeLPR and qualified lrat-check. A materially different formula constructor reproduced the base exactly, and proof truncations failed closed. These checks justify the exact local exclusion but not any broader ownership claim.
Claims requiring scrutiny- The q0-m0 cylinder with graph6 key Q???????????????OK[CwB@ooX? is UNSAT under the frozen 30-block completion encoding.
- Its complete DRAT has SHA-256 e87026fa9a16614904de48b17d46dc48325993889483a44dbce53efeb93dcbc3 and size 8757790 bytes.
- Its converted LRAT has SHA-256 bc1df8123ce77e87b9e8aad3372a663968aad19f48e6147e6da440643a5dcb79 and size 4537565 bytes.
- The global maintained range remains 30 <= C(15,6,3) <= 31.
Evidence and scope- Producer: python3 scripts/q0_m0_drat16_v1.py --out-dir artifacts/epoch89-20260811/q0-m0-drat16-v1 --seconds 60 --proof-cap-bytes 16777216.
- Checker: python3 checkers/check_q0_m0_drat16_v1.py --run-dir artifacts/epoch89-20260811/q0-m0-drat16-v1 --out artifacts/epoch89-20260811/q0-m0-drat16-independent-check.json.
- CaDiCaL exit 20 at 9310 conflicts; drat-trim reported VERIFIED; CakeLPR reported VERIFIED UNSAT.
- Independent receipt status PASS, no failures, decision CERTIFIED_LOCAL_Q0_M0_UNSAT.
Computational experiments- .proof-experiments/20260811-144829-22e37d: producer completed in 8.256 seconds; UNSAT, 8757790-byte DRAT and 4537565-byte LRAT.
- .proof-experiments/20260811-144903-833c87: independent audit completed in 8.905 seconds; PASS with nine controls.
Independent checkercheckers/check_q0_m0_drat16_v1.py uses a separate graph6 decoder and formula constructor, freshly compiles drat-trim, lrat-check, and CakeLPR, qualifies the LRAT replayers on a known-good full q3 proof, reconstructs q0-m0 byte-for-byte, reconverts the DRAT, and tests nine mutations.
Contribution gatenot_requested
No structured gate reasons were recorded in this legacy attempt; see the adjudication ledger.
- Original model outcome
- no_progress
- Public classification
- no_progress
Cross-domain transfers tested- Certified C(12,6,4) link-orbit decomposition -> predict that a fixed C(15,6,3) root-link cylinder can carry a compact replayable proof -> q0-m0 passed locally, but the required complete global orbit union is still absent.
Established facts- No normalized 30-block cover extends the q0-m0 labelled canonical four-block type-0 root-link prefix.
Complete DRAT/LRAT package and independent PASS receipt. · Graph6 key Q???????????????OK[CwB@ooX? under the frozen 49962-variable, 191161-clause encoding. · computed - The type-0 depth-four frontier contains exactly 2258 canonical prefix families.
Epoch-86 clean-room orbit closure and independent frontier audit. · Root-link degree type (8,4^13) through depth four under the declared hereditary filters. · computed - Every putative 30-block cover has every point in exactly 12 blocks.
Slack-zero incidence count 6*30 = 15*12 together with the point-degree lower bound. · Any 30-block C(15,6,3) covering. · proved
Ruled out in this epoch- A 30-block completion of q0-m0.
The exact frozen labelled prefix cylinder. · The independently reconstructed CNF is UNSAT. · DRAT e87026fa9a16614904de48b17d46dc48325993889483a44dbce53efeb93dcbc3; LRAT bc1df8123ce77e87b9e8aad3372a663968aad19f48e6147e6da440643a5dcb79; independent receipt PASS. · A demonstrated checker, formula-semantics, or certificate defect. - Promote q0-m0 UNSAT to a global exclusion.
All putative 30-block covers. · q0-m0 is one overlapping type-0 prefix cylinder; 2253 other type-0 cylinders and four other root-degree types remain. · The frozen manifest and clean-room frontier scope. · A complete independently checked coverage union across all five root-degree types with replayed terminal certificates.
Open leads- Materially strengthened constructive exact-degree-12 incidence search.
A single directly checked 30-block cover settles the target without proof-frontier ownership. · Add one new sound global structural constraint to a frozen incidence branch and compare it with a matched control under a short predeclared gate. · high · open - Hash-ranked proof-yield and storage pilot.
q0-m0 shows that 16 MiB ASCII-DRAT transport can terminate and replay, but representative yield and aggregate storage remain unknown. · After human approval, freeze a small sample disjoint from the five certified keys and replay every terminal leaf. · normal · open - Complete five-type root-link coverage bridge.
This is necessary before local cylinder certificates can support a global negative result. · Specify owner predicates and independently enumerate the first missing root-degree type under a bounded frontier cap. · low · open
Continuation checkpointObjective: Choose between a materially new constructive incidence discriminator and an owner-approved proof-yield pilot without overstating the local exclusion.
First action: Ask the human owner to approve the exact proof-pilot scope; absent approval, identify and compile one new sound global incidence constraint with a matched control.
Stop condition: Redirect on hash drift, cap or replay failure, missing ownership, or lack of a material encoding delta.
Next moves- Do not dispatch a larger proof pilot until the human owner approves its exact population, caps, aggregate storage gate, and stopping rule.
- Prefer a materially strengthened constructive exact-degree-12 incidence experiment because one checked 30-block witness bypasses the ownership bottleneck.
- For any negative scale-up, build independently checked coverage across all five root-degree types and replay every terminal leaf.
Citations
Tool disclosureGPT-5.6 Sol served as principal investigator. Two pre-completed GPT-5.6 Terra delegates supplied advisory prior-art and experiment-design memos; Sol audited their relied-on claims and model agreement was not validation. Deterministic work used CPython 3.12.3, CaDiCaL 1.7.3 seed 0, GCC 13.3.0, drat-trim, lrat-check, CakeLPR, SHA-256, exact graph6/CNF reconstruction, and the computational-researcher experiment harness. Web retrieval checked LJCR, the Covering Repository context, arXiv:2607.23766, and exact-phrase searches. No CAS, PB solver, proof assistant beyond CakeLPR's verified kernel, cloud lab, external proof service, human validator, system installation, publication action, or successor job dispatch was used.; orchestration: gpt-5.6-sol principal with gpt-5.6-terra delegates.
- Duration
- 1134.3s
- Review state
- evidence receipt failure; not durable progress
- Attempt ID
covering-c1563-20260811-145816-dd25f9
Human review ledgerNo human review recorded.